Nurse Job Counteroffers

So, you have gone through the entire interview process and been offered a new position. You inform your employer that you are leaving and then it hits you - the counteroffer.

This is great! Right? They want you stay - can't bear the thought of you leaving.

This is a pivotal point in your career advancement. It is critical to know in advance how you will handle the situation. Before you get carried away by the emotion ("You like me! You really like me!" Sally Fields, the Oscar's 1984) think about what is occuring:

Suddenly there is more money. Wasn't I worth it before? Have all I accomplished was to get my next pay raise early?

All of these (management, staffing, education, budgetary, etc.) problems are now promised to be fixed. If it was so difficult to fix before, why is it so easy to fix now?

The CEO, VP, etc. wants to talk to me. They were never interested in talking to me before - why now?

I'm right in the middle of a project. Have I ever not been in the middle of a project? Will there ever be a good time to change?

I'm thinking about accepting the counteroffer. Who is benefiting the most - me or my employer?

I have just broken ranks with my management and team. Does my manager still trust me? Will my peers and subordinates think me disloyal? Will they start to look for my replacement?

I was willing to uproot my family and move. Now I've changed my mind. Will my employer continue to view me as a decisive leader?

I usually get approval on this type of request. Have I lost influence because I thought about leaving but didn't, or is it something else?

Things did change for the better. Is the only way to bring about improvements in the organization is to threaten resignation? Is this the type of management under which I wish to continue my career?

A counteroffer may be extremely appealing in the short term, but in the long run its effects can be haunting. There are exceptions, but accepting a counteroffer will place you on uncertain footing with your management, peers and subordinates. It could become a hidden agenda for others in the organization.

So, first of all, think long and hard about what prompted you to consider making a change in the beginning. Then apply some critical thinking about whether the organization can truly bring about the changes that would induce you to stay. Is the counteroffer only a band aide?

Secondly, write a well thought out resignation letter that thanks your employer for the past opportunity they provided. Firmly state in the letter that your decision is final and that they should respect your wishes.

Here is additional food for thought from other sources including The Wall Street Journal Executive Career Site:

Copyright © 1998-2006 Silver Oak Search Consultants, Inc. All Rights Reserved.